Plans to close four South Devon community hospitals

Torbay and South Devon NHS foundation trust
(Last Updated On: January 20, 2017)

It has been proposed that four community hospitals in South Devon should be closed.

The proposal would see Ashburton, Bovey Tracey, Dartmouth and Paignton hospital shut.

In a statement released today South Devon and Torbay clinical commisioning group said:

“Members of South Devon and Torbay Clinical Commissioning Group’s Governing Body are being recommended to stick with proposals to switch resources from hospital bed-based care to community-based care so as to improve health services and meet increasing demand.

“They are being recommended to agree at their meeting on 26 January to the closure of four community hospitals – in Ashburton, Bovey Tracey, Dartmouth and Paignton – so as to free up resources to improve support to people at home in a move designed to improve health promotion, and reduce the number of people admitted and kept in hospital unnecessarily.

“But in light of feedback from last year’s consultation, they are being asked to approve three main changes to the proposals first published last April:

  • Evaluate Ashburton and Buckfastleigh Hospital as a base for the area’s local health and wellbeing centre, which would include GPs.
  • Recognise that demand for x-ray and for a minor injuries unit (MIU) in the Bay should be met by proposals to establish an urgent care centre on the Torbay Hospital site.
  • Enable specialist outpatient clinics to continue in Paignton where the volume of patients makes this a more appropriate option to travelling to Brixham, Totnes or Torbay.

“In response to public pressure to retain hospitals, the CCG’s clinically led Community Services Transformation Group states: “It is not sustainable to continue to spend as much money on hospital-based care where the evidence shows that supporting people in or near their own homes delivers better outcomes for many patients.”

“All suggestions put forward by the public as an alternative to the proposed model of care were evaluated in a three-stage process by the CCG.

“This involved representatives of organisations such as community hospitals’ Leagues of Friends, voluntary groups and local councils. The reasons for not pursuing any other changes are set out in the report to the CCG’s Governing Body, which is on the organisation’s website.

“In line with commitments made during consultation, the CCG Governing Body is also being asked to approve a series of parameters that must be met before any changes to existing services – such as MIUs open seven days a week, x-rays available for at least four hours a day, and alternative intermediate care services – are in place before hospitals close.

“In making these recommendations, the Governing Body is being advised that the proposals will deliver the changes needed to improve services and to support more people effectively in a way that is both sustainable and affordable.”

A petition appeared online following the announcement which stated:
“Dartmouth, being as remote and isolated as it is, relies heavily on having it’s own hospital especially as it has a very high percentage of elderly persons. Dartmouth Hospital is especially important because getting to Torbay Hospital from Dartmouth can often take almost an hour especially once you factor in waiting times for the ferry or navigating down windy roads.

“Those who need to be monitored in hospital and people who need to go for medical check-ups really benefit from having a local hospital near home. I urge the South Devon and Torbay Clinical Commissioning Group to reverse their decision regarding Dartmouth hospital,”

You can join us on our social media pages, follow us on Facebook or Twitter and keep up to date with whats going on in South Devon. Got a news story, blog or press release that you’d like to share? Contact us


Team account for We Are South Devon.